Categorized | News, OpEd, Opinion

Civil Forfeiture: Government Theft Without The Pretense

Don’t you hate when the government takes your money? Oh, sure, paying taxes that contribute to programs you don’t agree with is kind of a pain. But I’m actually talking about the government physically reaching into your pocket and taking all of our cash under threat of imprisonment.

Sounds like something only Denzel Washington would do in Training Day, right? In point of fact, right now, it is perfectly reasonable for a police officer in the United States to confiscate all of your valuables without even charging you with a crime. It’s called civil forfeiture, and it’s just as bad as it sounds.

Right about now is when everyone who has never had a negative encounter with the police comes out of the woodwork to say something like this: “If you don’t do anything wrong, the police won’t bother you.”

First of all, this argument is terrible on its own, because the police shouldn’t take advantage of anyone – even if they have done something wrong. Regrettably, America has less trust in our law enforcement officials than at any other point in our history. And with good reason.

In any event, what makes civil forfeiture especially outrageous is that it’s happening to people who have committed no crime except driving with large amounts of cash.

In one instance, a man was driving from Michigan to San Francisco with $2,400 in cash, which his dad had lent him to start a new business. He was pulled over in Nevada and asked for his license, registration, and how much money he was carrying.

The man was forthright with the officer and told him about the money he had in the trunk of his car. Suspecting the man was a drug dealer – because apparently drug dealers are the only people in America who carry around United States legal tender – the police officer called in a K9 unit. Guess what? The dog didn’t find anything. But, because the police officer still thought the man was driving to San Francisco to purchase drugs, he took the money.

And it was totally legal. The only part that surprises me is that the cop didn’t try to claim he was staging an intervention – you know, for the junkie’s own good. But he didn’t attempt even that level of pretense.

In a recent investigation into civil forfeiture, the Washington Post found that there have been 61,998 cash seizures since 9/11, and they total more than $2.5 billion. None of those seizures were made after law enforcement obtained a warrant or indictment.

The strange reason why this is all legal is that the police are only taking the property based on the belief that it was, or could be, used in the crime. They don’t need to prove beyond a reasonable doubt in a court of law that the money – or in some cases even houses and cars – they are taking were involved in a crime; all they have to say is that they believe there is a preponderance of evidence that this is the case.

The police officer then has absolute authority to take the money, which is rightfully owned by an American citizen. It then goes directly into his or her own department. Sound like a conflict of interest to anybody else?

You might think: Well, it isn’t like it’s going straight into their own pocket. The thing is though, thanks to shoddy record keeping, no one is exactly sure where it goes. In one of the few instances where money from civil forfeiture was accounted for in a police budget, it was found to be used to buy a margarita machine for a police department. Now that’s taking citizens’ money for some government waste if ever I’ve seen it.


Image Credit: Flickr (via and Creative Commons)

About Daniel Faris

Daniel Faris is a freelance journalist and a graduate of the Writers Institute at Susquehanna University. When he’s not blogging about politics on Only Slightly Biased, you can find his alter ego discussing progressive music at The Sound of Progress. He currently lives in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania.

6 Responses to “Civil Forfeiture: Government Theft Without The Pretense”

  1. Tom White says:

    It is frightening that America has become a police state where due process is thrown out the window. It is actions like this that has eroded faith and trust in Law Enforcement officials and there is no sign it is getting better. Great post!
    Tom White recently posted…Why I Am Voting for Ed Gillespie – Top 10 ReasonsMy Profile

  2. Mr. Green Jeans says:

    See pages 5 and 6 of Hanover County Board of Supervisors minutes . Communications funds for Hanover County schools paid for with civil asset forfeiture funds.

  3. Robert says:

    This is where a good lawyer comes in. America has become a police state, and nobody should have to take it on their own. A good firm like can save a lot of heartache and inconvenience.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge

Tom White Says:

Nothing is more conservative than a republican wanting to get their majority back. And nothing is more liberal than a republican WITH a majority.

Sign up for Virginia Right Once Daily Email Digest

No Spam - ever! We send a daily email with the posts of the previous day. Unsubscribe at any time.
* = required field

Follow Us Anywhere!